Skip to main content

How to Resolve Python Pylint Warning "String statement has no effect (pointless-string-statement)"

Pylint is a popular static analysis tool for Python that helps identify potential errors and enforce coding standards. One common warning it produces is String statement has no effect (pointless-string-statement). This usually indicates that you have a string literal (often a triple-quoted multiline string """...""" or '''...''') in your code that isn't assigned to a variable, isn't used as a docstring, and therefore doesn't actually do anything.

This guide explains the common causes of this warning, focusing on misplaced docstrings and attempts at multiline comments, and provides solutions.

Understanding the Warning: Pointless String Literals​

In Python, creating a string literal like "Hello" or """A multiline\nstring""" is technically a statement. However, if this string literal is not:

  • Assigned to a variable (my_string = "Hello").
  • Used as the first statement immediately following a module, function, class, or method definition (making it a docstring).
  • Passed as an argument to a function (print("Hello")).
  • Part of some larger expression.

...then the string is created but immediately discarded. It has no effect on the program's execution, hence Pylint flags it as "pointless". While not technically an error that crashes the program, it usually indicates code that's unnecessary, potentially leftover, or intended as a comment but implemented incorrectly.

Legitimate Uses of String Literals​

String literals do have effects when used correctly:

  • Assignment: message = "Welcome" stores the string.
  • Docstrings: Placed immediately after a definition, they document the object. Python tools and help systems use these. 
    """This is the module docstring."""

    def my_function(param):
        """This is the function docstring."""
        # ... function code ...

    class MyClass:
        """This is the class docstring."""
        def my_method(self):
            """This is the method docstring."""
            # ... method code ...
  • Function Arguments: print("Log message"), process_data("input_string").

The Pylint warning targets strings that don't fall into these categories.

Cause 1: Misplaced Docstring​

A very common cause is writing a docstring but placing it incorrectly, most often after import statements instead of as the very first statement in the module.

Error Scenario

import os # Import first

"""This module processes files.""" # ⛔️ String statement has no effect (pointless-string-statement)
# Pylint sees this after the import, so it's not a valid module docstring.

print(f"Current dir: {os.getcwd()}")

Solution 1: Position Docstrings Correctly​

Module, function, class, and method docstrings must be the very first statement immediately following the def or class line (or at the top of the file for module docstrings), before any other code or imports (for modules).

"""This module processes files.""" # ✅ Correct: Module docstring at the top.

import os # Imports come AFTER the module docstring.

def process_file(filename):
    """Reads and processes the specified file.""" # ✅ Correct: Function docstring first.
    print(f"Processing {filename}...")
    # ... other code ...

print(f"Current dir: {os.getcwd()}")

Cause 2: Using Triple-Quoted Strings as Multiline Comments​

Python does not have dedicated syntax for multiline comments like some other languages (e.g., /* ... */). Developers sometimes mistakenly use triple-quoted strings """...""" or '''...''' hoping they act as multiline comments. While the Python interpreter often ignores these "pointless" strings, Pylint correctly flags them because they are valid string statements that aren't being used.

Error Scenario

user = "Alice"
print(f"User: {user}")

"""
This is intended as a comment block
explaining the next section of code.
But it's actually just a pointless string statement.
""" # ⛔️ String statement has no effect (pointless-string-statement)

# More code follows...

Solution 2: Use Hash (#) for Comments​

The correct way to write comments in Python (single or multi-line) is to start each comment line with the hash symbol (#).

user = "Alice"
print(f"User: {user}")

# ✅ Correct: This is a proper comment block.
# Each line starts with '#'.
# Explaining the next section of code.

# More code follows...

Most code editors provide shortcuts (like Ctrl+/ or Cmd+/) to comment/uncomment selected blocks of lines using the # prefix.

Solution 3 (Optional): Disable the Pylint Warning​

If you have a specific reason to keep a string statement that Pylint flags (perhaps using it intentionally for a very specific framework or metaprogramming reason, though this is rare), or if you choose to use triple-quoted strings as block comments despite the convention, you can disable the pointless-string-statement warning. This is generally not recommended as it hides potentially unused code or unconventional commenting styles.

Disabling via pylintrc File​

  1. Find or create a pylintrc file in your project root or user directory.
  2. Locate the [MESSAGES CONTROL] section.
  3. Add pointless-string-statement to the disable= list (comma-separated). 
    [MESSAGES CONTROL]
    # Add the warning ID to the disable list
    disable=...,pointless-string-statement,...

Disabling via VS Code settings.json (User or Workspace)​

  1. Open VS Code settings (JSON).
    • User Settings: Ctrl+Shift+P -> Preferences: Open User Settings (JSON)
    • Workspace Settings: Create .vscode/settings.json in your project root.
  2. Add or modify the python.linting.pylintArgs setting: 
    {
        "python.linting.pylintArgs": [
            "--disable=pointless-string-statement"
            // Add other Pylint args here if needed
        ]
    }

This will prevent Pylint (when run via the VS Code extension) from showing this specific warning. Remember, this only silences the linter; it doesn't change how Python interprets the code.

Conclusion​

The Pylint warning String statement has no effect (pointless-string-statement) highlights string literals in your code that aren't assigned, used as docstrings, or part of larger expressions.

The primary solutions are:

  1. Position Docstrings Correctly: Ensure module, function, class, and method docstrings are the very first statement after the definition line or at the top of the file.
  2. Use # for Comments: Replace triple-quoted strings intended as comments with lines starting with the hash symbol (#).
  3. Remove Unused Strings: If the string literal is genuinely leftover or unused code, simply delete it.

Disabling the warning should be a deliberate choice made only if you understand the implications and have a specific reason for keeping the "pointless" string statement. Following standard Python conventions for docstrings and comments is the best way to avoid this warning.

Table of Contents